No, it is
not the humanity, or the humility of it all.
Neither of those was even vaguely recognizable as having been present at
the time.
I think
that I, a totally unknown and spectacularly insignificant weblogist who has no
expertise in North Africa and the Middle East and who has never been to any of
the areas in question and has no desire whatsoever to correct that terrible
deficiency, can nevertheless come up with a totally logical and therefore
credible explanation of what the wave of riots that have been sweeping the
Islamic world is all about.
That is
because exactly the same sort of thing happened right here in the U.S. a mere
44 years ago, and having been an adult of 37 in that year with all my faculties
and brain processes reasonably intact, and also by having been a longtime
citizen of the chief focal spot of American turmoil in that era (and in most
other eras as well, wouldn't you say?), the Nation's Capital, I, unlike the great majority of Americans today, was around and conscious for the
riots that were so common in the U.S. in that year of 1968, specifically right
after Martin Luther King was shot and killed in Memphis. Of course, by not being that ridiculous
entity called a ubiquitous god, I couldn't have been in all the many spots that
were so widely hit by the disorders all at one time. But if you just so happened to live in one
of those several rainbow (i.e. "black" neighborhoods that were involved
in D.C, as I did, you would essentially have seen and been affected -- that is
to say, to some degree scarred -- by it
all.
Quite
naturally, having been born with no sort of stomach for any of that kind of
garbage, I didn't personally witness any of that burning and pillage and the
conflicts with the police. All of that
was easily replicated by the imagination.
I stayed at home with my wife and my mother, several blocks from the
nearest action, which involved severe damage to the big building on Bladensburg
Road that housed the beloved and highly necessary local Sears Roebuck. Mainly I just sat around uneasily, catching
whiffs of the smoke and listening to the distant roar and ruckus, punctuated by
the never before heard sounds, at least so close together -- maybe because D.C,
and Federal laws prohibited such sorties as they did the building of excessively
tall buildings -- of regular, loud, and threatening overflights of military
helicopters overhead.
Later I
also wrote what I think is a pretty good poem about what that was like. Maybe I'll dig it out and for the first time
give it whatever I have of the light of day here.
I expect
that most authorities and experts will strongly disagree with me, because they
have a myriad of other kinds of much more authoritative-sounding ideas and
motivations that serve the purposes of their comfort zones, which must always
be different from mine because even most people of my color who are around today have not had to
live under the abiding indignity of official Jim Crow, or of the invasion, the
confiscation, and the occupation that the Palestinians have been forced to
endure at the hands of the Israelis for so many years. But my attitude will always be, what do they
know? So I'm saying that those MLK
riots of early April 1968 mainly stemmed from long-sustained racial
humiliation, the "H" that I referred to, and I think that exactly the same thing can be said about what has
been going on lately in so many of the Islamic countries, from Tunisia at least
a third of the way around the globe to Indonesia, and that the insult of a
badly made film to the Prophet Muhammad was merely an excuse for the rampaging
and the flames, as was the killing of Dr. King.
But what
else can be expected?
The
Muslims saw European powers who traditionally billed themselves as being
naturally superior to all other groups on earth, not the Chosen but the Favored People, appropriate for themselves by
force of arms large swathes of what had been the lands of Muslims for
centuries, including most of what stretched far to the south and the east of
the Mediterranean.
A little later, either in a rare moment of
largeness of heart or, more likely, while thinking they would thereby hear no
more from a group of what they regarded as nuisances who saw one particular
part of those Arab lands as being their ancestral homeland, though few of the
Zionists' people had tended the olive groves
there for nearly two thousand years, the most voracious of those powers when it
came to trying to gobble up other people's territory, the British, set aside
that one small parcel as a refuge for those who had just recently managed to
avoid the otherwise successful attempt by the Germans to exterminate every Jewish
person that they could put their hands on -- one of the great war crimes of the
Second World War, along with the even more gigantic losses of their kinfolk
that the Russians and the Chinese suffered at the hands of those same endlessly
homicidal Germans and the Japanese respectively.
The
Muslims recalled, however, that it turned out that the British hadn't really
done the resulting sudden influx of newly anointed Israelis a favor, just as as
they had done less than nothing for those Muslims who had already been living
in that same spot seemingly forever, even though to the uninformed eye that
"precious place" appeared to be notably lacking in the virtues of
almost any piece of land outside the worst of the Sahara Desert. I mean when it came to the really valuable
holy stuff, like enough rain and features other than ruins, rocks, sand, and
scrubby vegetation.
Instead
these aspiring "returnees" found themselves condemned to plunking
themselves right down in the midst of numerous Muslims who could say that not only
had their ancient ancestors lived there at the same time as the fabled but
deposed ancient ancestors of the returnees, but also all their later ancestors
had lived there in all the subsequent centuries as well, while the matching
generations of these returnees had been mainly swinging around Europe instead,
being alternately hideously despoiled and grudgingly cohabited with by the
Europeans, so much so that ethnically the Jews had become a different people
and no longer Semitic at all, but instead were essentially indistinguishable
from Russians, Germans, and English folk.
However,
if they wanted to stay in that Promised Land, the Israelis saw nothing for it
but to use the same methods against the Palestinians that had been employed
against their now wholesalely departed kin with such devastating efficiency and
success by the Germans.
Soon
enough the Israelis likewise succeeded in that first stage of ethnic cleansing
while settling in, but only at the cost of selling their souls and wasting the
enormous moral capital that they had been given by the Holocaust. This put them in a trap from which today
they have no hope of emerging, because of their habit of choosing leaders who
choose only to add to the heights of those unspeakable walls snaking
through the West Bank and Gaza that will only make a big mess when soon enough they
will have to be torn down again and that meanwhile seal them off from the rest
of humanity, though they think that instead those barriers keep them
comfortably safe from the people that they have so busily been dispossessing
and disenfranchising in the same barbarous ways that so habitually were used
against their forerunners on another continent.
But
though those walls may make the Palestinians largely invisible to the Israelis,
the Palestinians can still be easily seen by everybody in the Islamic world,
and therefore we have the riots of today.
The
Palestinians are the clearest indicators of the sustained racial humiliation to
the Arabs, the Persians, and all the others in the Middle East and North Africa
and elsewhere have long felt inflicted on them by the Western nations, and due
to one thing or another, including the time-honored one among all humans of the
Arabs and the Persians adhering to leaders who don't lead at all but merely
exploit, they have been unable to ward off these indignities.
It is
exactly the same humiliation that for generations the descendants of the slaves
brought over from Africa have felt in the U.S., coupled with that same
powerlessness to do much about it.
Therefore some, a very small number among them, almost entirely young
males careless of their lives, now and then resort to expressing their rage at
the humiliation and helplessness that they found waiting for them when they
came of age. When enough of them can
gather in one place, they resort to going out into the streets and raising a
big ruckus -- even if to no useful purpose other than to blow off steam, and
ultimately also to no avail, so that I likened it -- in the case of the Martin Luther King riots
as also now in the Islamic riots -- to the act of defecating in one's own
bathtub.
This is
because the riots end up hurting only the rioters themselves, while having no
effect at all on their oppressors, least of all on the Israeli and American
guilty consciences. The few businesses
and other enterprises that have seen their way to set up shop in the rioters'
neighborhoods are torched and destroyed in the riots, and they are not replaced
quickly, if at all, for fear of the same thing happening all over again. I saw that happen in D.C. and afterward, and
it stands to happen in Tunisia, Egypt and all those other places today.
For all
that, in the long run, one still finds himself feeling fortunate when he is
reminded that, mainly by birth, he is not a member of the groups with the power
and the intent to keep another group in a state of subjugation for years and
even centuries on end. He finds that he
can feel the same way that, as Albert Camus assured us, Sisyphus did, not at
the moment when he finally got the boulder pushed up to the top of the hill. No, the relief comes at that other moment
when one finds the rock again after it has slipped out of his grasp and has
rolled all the way back down to the bottom of the hill. At that point he can press his cheek to the
stone and thereby can feel that cold and seemingly intractable and diabolical grainy
surface impart to him an exquisite and supreme happiness that is always denied
to the gods and those who are responsible for that rock never staying in place
at the top of the hill.
I
suppose, though, that the rioters, the several who do any thinking at all, see themselves as putting the first little
crack in that rock, after which water freezing and expanding in subsequent
winters will eventually bust that rock to pieces, so that it can never roll
anywhere again.